Perni Nani says Naidu must answer on Tirumala ghee case

Former Andhra Pradesh Minister Perni Venkataramaiah (Nani) on Saturday accused the Chandrababu Naidu-led government of using the Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams ghee adulteration case for political propaganda. Speaking at the YSRCP central office, he said a recent Enforcement Directorate statement had brought facts to light and Naidu must answer for his allegations. The ED arrested Kailash Chand Mangla for allegedly facilitating manufacture of adulterated ghee. Nani said the SIT recovered not a single rupee in the liquor case in two years.

Written by AI from TDP (N. Chandrababu Naidu) · not yet reviewed by an editor · Published 19 Sept 2026, 8:38 pm IST

Source

TDP (N. Chandrababu Naidu) · read the original report ↗

#ysrcp#tdp#tirumala laddu#enforcement directorate#andhra pradesh

Desk check · some claims need care

What the desk checked (5)

ED arrested co-conspirator Kailash Chand Mangla in the TTD ghee adulteration case for facilitating procurement of adulterants and manufacturing adulterated ghee at his factory. — Attributed to the Enforcement Directorate in the source; no independent confirmation possible here.
Adulterated ghee was made using Refined Palm Oil, Palm Kernel Oil, Palmolein and chemicals including MG-90, Monoglycerides, Myvacet Soft 400 and Acetic Acid Ester, and supplied as Agmark Special Grade Cow Ghee to TTD. — Quoted directly from the ED investigation as cited in the source.
SIT investigated the liquor case for nearly two years without recovering even one rupee. — Allegation by Perni Nani; no supporting data or official source given.
TDP leaders' scam figure fell from Rs 1 lakh crore to Rs 44,000 crore, Rs 33,000 crore and then Rs 3,000 crore. — Figures asserted by Perni Nani only; unattributed to any official record.
Accused Satyaprasad was allowed bail and turned into an approver, with a statement containing only hearsay. — Allegation by the YSRCP leader; no official or court source cited.

Written by AI from TDP (N. Chandrababu Naidu) · not yet reviewed by an editor · How we use AI · Report an error

Analysts’ view opinion

AI Political Analyst

This is the YSRCP shifting from defence to counter-attack. Perni Nani is using the ED's latest move — the arrest of Kailash Chand Mangla — to anchor a narrative that the Tirumala ghee adulteration was a supplier-side crime rather than a political scandal, and to demand that Chandrababu Naidu answer for his allegations. Pairing that with the claim that the SIT has recovered nothing in two years in the liquor case is an attempt to put the credibility of the investigations themselves on trial. For now this remains one party's argument; the government's response is not part of this story.

Cornered on an emotive issue involving Tirumala prasadam, the YSRCP is leveraging the ED arrest to push the conversation towards adulterating suppliers rather than political culpability.
By bundling in Super Six promises, drought-hit farmers, DSC recruitment and unemployment, Perni Nani is trying to convert a case-centred debate into a governance-delivery debate.
The 'Rs 1 lakh crore down to Rs 3,000 crore' framing works as pre-emptive political armour, letting the party dismiss future allegations as inflated.
Questioning how Satyaprasad moved from accused to approver is aimed at seeding doubt about process — fighting the case in public opinion well before any courtroom verdict.
The ruling coalition's risk is timing: if the probes do not produce visible outcomes, the 'never-ending serial' line can gain traction with neutral voters.

What to watch — Watch whom the agencies target next in both the ghee and liquor cases, and how sharply the TDP-led coalition rebuts Perni Nani — that exchange will set the political tone of the coming weeks.

Everything here is an opposition leader's allegation; the story does not establish that the cases were politically misused, does not establish any leader's involvement or innocence, and carries no government rebuttal.

Deep dive

Research brief · 8 facts · 3 dates · exam-ready

The brief

Context

The Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams (TTD), which manages the Tirumala temple and its famous laddu prasadam, has been at the centre of a ghee adulteration controversy, with the Enforcement Directorate investigating the supply of adulterated ghee passed off as Agmark Special Grade Cow Ghee. Separately, a Special Investigation Team (SIT) of the TDP-led coalition government in Andhra Pradesh has been probing an alleged liquor scam involving former Chief Minister YS Jagan Mohan Reddy. On September 19, former minister Perni Venkataramaiah (Nani) of the YSRCP used the ED's latest action to argue that Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu had turned both cases into political propaganda.

Key facts

Former AP Minister Perni Venkataramaiah (Nani) spoke to the media at the YSRCP central office in Tadepalli on Saturday, September 19.
The ED arrested Kailash Chand Mangla, described as a co-conspirator in the TTD ghee adulteration case, for allegedly procuring adulterants and manufacturing adulterated ghee at his factory.
As per the ED, the adulterated ghee was made using Refined Palm Oil, Palm Kernel Oil, Palmolein and chemicals including MG-90, Monoglycerides, Myvacet Soft 400 and Acetic Acid Ester.
The ED says the product was supplied to TTD as Agmark Special Grade Cow Ghee.
Perni Nani said the SIT probed the liquor case for nearly two years but failed to recover even one rupee.
He said TDP leaders first called it a Rs 1 lakh crore scam, and the figure was later reduced to Rs 44,000 crore, then Rs 33,000 crore, then Rs 3,000 crore.
He alleged that Satyaprasad, earlier shown as an accused, is being turned into an approver, and that his statement contains only hearsay and no direct evidence.
He demanded verification of TET marks, merit records and caste certificates of newly appointed teachers, and a comparison of the 2018 and latest DSC lists.

Timeline

Nearly two years (period stated in source)SIT investigates the alleged Andhra Pradesh liquor scam; Perni Nani says not even one rupee was recovered.
Before September 19 (date not stated)ED arrests Kailash Chand Mangla in the TTD ghee adulteration case and issues a statement on the adulterants used.
Saturday, September 19Perni Nani addresses media at the YSRCP central office in Tadepalli, demanding answers from Chandrababu Naidu.

Who has a stake

Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams (TTD) — Its prasadam supply chain and credibility are at stake, having allegedly received adulterated ghee labelled as Agmark Special Grade Cow Ghee.
Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu and the TDP coalition government — Accused by YSRCP of using the ghee and liquor cases for propaganda; must answer on the ED findings and SIT's record.
YSRCP and YS Jagan Mohan Reddy — Jagan is the target of the liquor scam probe; the party is using the ED statement to counter what it calls political targeting.
Enforcement Directorate (ED) — Conducting the ghee adulteration investigation; its statement and arrest form the factual basis of the political row.
Special Investigation Team (SIT) — Its nearly two-year liquor case probe is under attack for recovering no money and for shifting scam estimates.
DSC candidates, teachers, students and unemployed youth — Alleged recruitment irregularities, drought relief and unfulfilled Super Six promises affect their entitlements and jobs.

Why it matters

The case sits at the intersection of temple administration, food adulteration and electoral politics, where a matter of religious faith — the Tirumala prasadam — has become a partisan battleground. It also raises the question of whether high-profile investigations by central and state agencies produce recoveries and convictions, or mainly serve narrative-building, since the SIT is alleged to have recovered nothing in two years while scam estimates fell from Rs 1 lakh crore to Rs 3,000 crore.

UPSC angle

Prelims pointers

Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams (TTD) manages the Tirumala temple; the ghee adulteration case concerns supplies for its prasadam.
Enforcement Directorate arrested Kailash Chand Mangla in the TTD ghee adulteration case.
ED named adulterants: Refined Palm Oil, Palm Kernel Oil, Palmolein, MG-90, Monoglycerides, Myvacet Soft 400, Acetic Acid Ester.
The ghee was allegedly supplied as 'Agmark Special Grade Cow Ghee' — Agmark is a certification mark for agricultural produce.
Super Six: set of promises attributed in the story to the TDP coalition government in Andhra Pradesh.
DSC (District Selection Committee) recruitment is the process for teacher appointments; TET marks are cited for verification.

Mains framing

The Andhra Pradesh row over the TTD ghee adulteration case and the alleged liquor scam illustrates how criminal investigations can be absorbed into political competition. On one side is a documented enforcement action: the ED's arrest of Kailash Chand Mangla and its account of ghee made from palm oil derivatives and chemicals such as MG-90 and Acetic Acid Ester, yet marketed as Agmark Special Grade Cow Ghee — a failure of procurement and quality assurance in a major temple institution. On the other side, the opposition YSRCP argues that the ruling coalition has instrumentalised both cases: it points to an SIT probe of nearly two years with no recovery, scam estimates sliding from Rs 1 lakh crore to Rs 44,000 crore, Rs 33,000 crore and Rs 3,000 crore, and an accused, Satyaprasad, allegedly converted into an approver on hearsay evidence. The implications run to institutional credibility — of the ED, the SIT and temple administration alike — and to public trust in religious offerings. A way forward, on the material in the source, would involve transparent disclosure of the evidentiary basis and recoveries in the liquor case, clarity on why an accused was not arrested before becoming an approver, published norms and audit of TTD's ghee procurement, transparency in liquor-shop tenders and the Rs 99 quality liquor promise, and a comprehensive inquiry comparing the 2018 and latest DSC lists with verification of TET marks, merit and caste certificates.

Key terms

TTD (Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams): The body that administers the Tirumala temple and its prasadam supplies, to which the allegedly adulterated ghee was sent.
Enforcement Directorate (ED): Central financial investigation agency; it arrested Kailash Chand Mangla and detailed the alleged adulterants in the ghee case.
Agmark Special Grade Cow Ghee: The certified grade label under which the allegedly adulterated ghee was supplied to TTD, per the ED.
SIT (Special Investigation Team): Team probing the alleged Andhra liquor scam; Perni Nani says it recovered not one rupee in nearly two years.
Approver: An accused who turns witness for the prosecution; Perni Nani alleges Satyaprasad is being converted into one.
Super Six: Set of election promises Perni Nani says the TDP coalition government has failed to implement.

Practice questions

Critically examine how high-profile investigations into temple administration and excise policy can become instruments of political contestation, using the Andhra Pradesh TTD ghee and liquor cases as illustrations.
What institutional safeguards can strengthen quality assurance and procurement integrity in the supply of food articles to major religious institutions?
Discuss the legal and ethical questions raised when an accused is converted into an approver in a criminal investigation.

Grounded only in the source report — figures and dates are the source's, not inferred.

Next storyNeha Thakur leaves air hostess training to drive trucks in Himachal →

← All stories