Carbon emission blame wrongly placed on developing nations: Modi

Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on Saturday that responsibility for carbon emissions is often "wrongly placed" on developing countries. Speaking at the International Conference on 'The Future of Environment and Climate Dynamics' at Vigyan Bhawan in New Delhi, he said India's per capita carbon emissions are less than half of the global average. He said India is the only G-20 nation to have met its Paris (COP-21) commitments ahead of schedule. The two-day conference, organised by the National Green Tribunal on September 19 and 20, includes judges from 17 countries.

Written by AI from Hindustan Times — India · not yet reviewed by an editor · Published 19 Sept 2026, 12:58 pm IST

Source

Hindustan Times — India · read the original report ↗

#narendra modi#climate change#carbon emissions#ngt#renewable energy

Desk check · compared with the source

What the desk checked (5)

Responsibility for carbon emissions has often been "wrongly placed" on developing countries. — Direct quote attributed to PM Modi in the source; opinion statement, not independently verified.
India's per capita carbon emissions are less than half of the global average. — Attributed to PM Modi in a quoted remark; no supporting data or agency cited in the source.
India is the only G-20 country to have fulfilled its COP-21 Paris commitments ahead of schedule. — Stated by PM Modi in a direct quote; no third-party verification in the source.
The two-day conference is organised by the National Green Tribunal on September 19-20, with judicial representatives from 17 countries. — Attributed to the NGT and event details listed in the source; figure appears in source.
President Murmu will attend the valedictory session on Sunday. — Scheduled event reported in the source; forward-looking, unverified.

Written by AI from Hindustan Times — India · not yet reviewed by an editor · How we use AI · Report an error

Analysts’ view opinion

AI Political Analyst

This is a diplomatic-political statement delivered in the form of a climate speech. By stressing that India's per capita emissions are less than half the global average and that India is the only G-20 country to have met its Paris commitments ahead of schedule, PM Modi is positioning India as the voice of the developing world. The explicit reference to the Global South is not incidental — it signals that India is not letting go of the historical-responsibility argument aimed at richer nations.

The claim that emissions blame is "wrongly placed" reinforces India's long-standing negotiating posture on the right to development and historical responsibility.
Framing progress over "the past 12 years" carries a domestic political message too, crediting climate gains to the current government's tenure.
The venue matters: an NGT-hosted event with the CJI, the Attorney General and judges from 17 countries lets India present itself as a standard-setter on environmental justice.
It is a step in India's broader bid for leadership of the Global South, with the likely aim of strengthening bargaining power in upcoming climate talks.
On the other side, critics and opposition voices may counter that per capita figures obscure total emissions, coal dependence and local pollution — though no such reaction is recorded in this story.

What to watch — Watch the roadmap emerging after Sunday's valedictory session, and how firmly India carries this historical-responsibility argument into the next round of international climate negotiations.

The story only records the Prime Minister's assertions — it offers no independent verification of the emissions figures, no opposition or foreign reaction, and no new policy announcement.

Deep dive

Research brief · 8 facts · 3 dates · exam-ready

The brief

Context

Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurated a two-day International Conference on 'The Future of Environment and Climate Dynamics' at Vigyan Bhawan, New Delhi, organised by the National Green Tribunal (NGT) on September 19 and 20. Addressing judges, government officials and environmental experts, he argued that the responsibility for carbon emissions has often been "wrongly placed" on developing countries, citing India's per capita emissions as less than half the global average. The conference brings together judicial, governmental and legal stakeholders, including judges from 17 countries, to discuss environmental justice and climate challenges.

Key facts

PM Modi said responsibility for carbon emissions has often been "wrongly placed" on developing countries, addressing delegates including colleagues from the Global South.
He said India's per capita carbon emissions are "less than half of the global average".
He said India is the only G-20 country to have fulfilled its COP-21 (Paris) commitments ahead of schedule.
He said India has made extraordinary progress in environment-linked sectors over the past 12 years, with renewable energy as the major focus, including non-fossil fuel capacity and solar energy.
The two-day conference was organised by the National Green Tribunal on September 19 and 20 at Vigyan Bhawan, New Delhi.
Judges and judicial representatives from 17 countries are participating, along with Supreme Court, High Court and district court judges and senior officials.
Inaugural session attendees included Chief Justice of India Justice Surya Kant, Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav, Attorney General R Venkataramani and NGT Chairperson Justice Prakash Shrivastava.
The event features four technical sessions and aims to develop a roadmap for present and future environmental and climate challenges.

Timeline

September 19 (Saturday)PM Modi inaugurates the International Conference on 'The Future of Environment and Climate Dynamics' at Vigyan Bhawan, New Delhi, and makes the carbon emissions remarks.
September 19-20NGT-organised two-day conference runs with four technical sessions on key environmental issues.
September 20 (Sunday)Valedictory session to be attended by President Droupadi Murmu, Union Minister Manohar Lal, Justice PS Narasimha, NGT Chairperson Justice Prakash Shrivastava and Solicitor General Tushar Mehta.

Who has a stake

National Green Tribunal (NGT) — Organiser of the conference; seeks to strengthen environmental justice and institutional cooperation through dialogue among judicial and government stakeholders.
Government of India / PM Modi — Asserting India's climate record - per capita emissions, renewable energy push and early fulfilment of Paris commitments - in the global equity debate.
Developing countries and the Global South — At the centre of the argument that blame for historical carbon emissions is misplaced on them rather than on industrialised nations.
Judiciary (CJI Surya Kant, Supreme Court, High Court and district judges, judges from 17 countries) — Adjudicates environmental disputes; conference is a platform to share practices and strengthen environmental justice.
State-level environmental bodies (SEACs, SEIAAs, State Wetland Authorities, State Legal Services Authorities) — Implementing agencies whose policy and implementation gaps the conference aims to identify.
Union Environment Ministry and law officers (Bhupender Yadav, AG R Venkataramani, SG Tushar Mehta) — Shape and defend India's environmental policy and regulatory framework.

Why it matters

The question of who bears responsibility for historical carbon emissions is central to global climate negotiations, and India's per capita emissions argument is its main equity plank in those talks. By making the case before an audience of judges from 17 countries at an NGT conference, the government links India's climate diplomacy to the domestic and international judicial conversation on environmental justice.

UPSC angle

Prelims pointers

National Green Tribunal (NGT) organised the International Conference on 'The Future of Environment and Climate Dynamics', September 19-20, Vigyan Bhawan, New Delhi.
NGT Chairperson: Justice Prakash Shrivastava; Chief Justice of India named in the source: Justice Surya Kant.
Union Environment, Forest and Climate Change Minister: Bhupender Yadav; Attorney General: R Venkataramani; Solicitor General: Tushar Mehta.
PM Modi: India's per capita carbon emissions are less than half of the global average.
PM Modi: India is the only G-20 nation to have met its COP-21 (Paris) commitments ahead of schedule.
Conference participants include judges and judicial representatives from 17 countries; four technical sessions planned.

Mains framing

The Prime Minister's remark that carbon emission responsibility is \"wrongly placed\" on developing countries restates the core equity dispute in climate governance: cumulative historical emissions came largely from industrialised economies, while developing nations face pressure to curb future emissions even as they pursue growth. India's counter-argument rests on per capita emissions - stated in the source as less than half the global average - and on performance, with the claim that it is the only G-20 country to have met its Paris (COP-21) commitments ahead of schedule on the back of renewable energy, non-fossil fuel capacity and solar expansion. Significantly, this argument was made at a judicial forum: the NGT conference brings judges from 17 countries, Supreme Court and High Court judges, and state bodies such as SEACs, SEIAAs and State Wetland Authorities into a conversation about gaps in policy-making and implementation. The way forward suggested by the conference's own stated aims is institutional - sharing successful practices, strengthening cooperation among stakeholders, building a roadmap for future climate challenges, and reinforcing environmental justice so that development, environment and adjudication reinforce rather than obstruct one another.

Key terms

National Green Tribunal (NGT): India's specialised environmental adjudication body; organiser of the two-day international conference, headed by Chairperson Justice Prakash Shrivastava.
COP-21 / Paris commitments: Climate pledges made at the Paris Summit; PM Modi said India is the only G-20 nation to have fulfilled them ahead of schedule.
Per capita carbon emissions: Emissions divided by population; India's figure is less than half the global average, per the PM's statement.
Global South: Grouping of developing countries; the PM noted colleagues from the Global South were present at the conference.
SEIAA / SEAC: State Environment Impact Assessment Authorities and State Expert Appraisal Committees, state-level environmental clearance bodies represented at the conference.
Non-fossil fuel capacity: Power generation capacity from sources other than coal, oil and gas; cited as an area of India's progress along with solar energy.

Practice questions

Critically examine the argument that responsibility for carbon emissions is "wrongly placed" on developing countries. How do per capita and historical emissions frame the climate equity debate?
Discuss the role of specialised bodies like the National Green Tribunal in strengthening environmental justice and bridging gaps between environmental policy-making and implementation in India.
"India is the only G-20 nation to have met its Paris commitments ahead of schedule." Assess the significance of such claims for India's climate diplomacy with the Global South.

Grounded only in the source report — figures and dates are the source's, not inferred.

Next storyThree main contenders in DUSU president race as counting continues →

← All stories