Burhanpur startup CEO counters Goyal's remarks on innovation

Speaking at Startup Mahakumbh 2025 in New Delhi, Union Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal said Indian startups must focus on deep-tech and AI instead of stopping at ice creams, chips and food delivery apps. The remarks drew criticism. Murtaza Amin, who runs a software company with 100 employees in Burhanpur, Madhya Pradesh, tweeted that he lacks 24/7 power supply, must pay bribes for every task, and travels 60 km to Khandwa for GST and PF offices.

Written by AI from Startups · not yet reviewed by an editor · Published 27 Sept 2026, 6:09 am IST

Source

Startups · read the original report ↗

#startups#piyush goyal#deep tech#burhanpur#entrepreneurship

Desk check · some claims need care

What the desk checked (5)

Piyush Goyal urged startups at Startup Mahakumbh 2025 in New Delhi to move to deep-tech instead of ice cream, chips and delivery apps — Attributed to the Union Commerce and Industry Minister at a named event; quotes appear in source
Zepto CEO Aditya Palicha said Zepto succeeded in job creation and attracting FDI; ex-Infosys CFO Mohandas Pai said Goyal should trust domestic startups — Attributed to named individuals in source; source renders the Zepto CEO's name as Adit Palicha
Murtaza Amin runs a software company in Burhanpur with 100 employees and about a million dollars in annual revenue — Self-reported by the CEO in his tweets; no independent corroboration in source
No 24/7 power supply, bribes for every task, and GST/PF offices 60 km away in Khandwa — Allegations attributed to Murtaza Amin; no official response cited
He wrote to the PMO, IAS officers and Goyal's office last month and received no response; PMO forwarded the complaint to the MP Labour Commissioner — Claimed by Amin; unverified, no government confirmation in source

Written by AI from Startups · not yet reviewed by an editor · How we use AI · Report an error

Analysts’ view opinion

AI Economic Analyst

Goyal's remarks express a demand-side aspiration — move up to deep-tech and AI; Murtaza Amin's tweets describe the supply-side reality. R&D-led innovation needs patient capital, reliable power and low transaction costs, yet the absence of 24/7 electricity, alleged bribes for routine work and GST/PF offices 60 km away in Khandwa act as an invisible tax that raises the cost of doing business in tier-2 and tier-3 towns. When those costs are high, capital and talent naturally drift to quick-commerce and delivery models with faster payback — meaning the outcome Goyal criticised is partly produced by the system itself.

Deep-tech requires longer horizons and more patient capital than snacks or delivery apps, and such capital follows policy predictability and infrastructure.
Power outages and rent-seeking are costs that never appear on a balance sheet but erode margins, penalising small-town firms against metro rivals.
Travelling 60 km for GST and PF compliance is a direct productivity loss and suggests ease-of-business reform has not fully reached the district level.
If the firm shuts, the loss is intensely local: 100 white-collar jobs, dependent households and local consumption, with thin alternative employment in a tier-2 town.
The other side has force too: as Zepto's CEO argued, consumer tech is already generating jobs and attracting FDI, so it is a complement to deep-tech rather than a substitute.

What to watch — Watch whether the PMO, the commerce ministry or the Madhya Pradesh administration responds substantively, and whether district-level GST/PF access and power reliability improve.

This rests on one founder's account: the allegations of bribery and official harassment are not independently verified, and the story carries no response from the authorities named nor audited financials of the company.

Deep dive

Research brief · 8 facts · 5 dates · exam-ready

The brief

Context

At Startup Mahakumbh 2025 in New Delhi, Union Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal urged Indian startups to move beyond consumer tech and delivery services towards deep-tech and AI innovation, asking whether making ice creams, chips and delivering groceries quickly counts as innovation. The remarks triggered sharp pushback from founders and investors. Among the critics was Murtaza Amin, who runs a software company employing 100 people in Burhanpur, Madhya Pradesh, who said the state does not provide even basic enablers such as round-the-clock power, corruption-free offices or nearby GST and PF offices. His tweets turned the debate from ambition to ground-level ease of doing business in small-town India.

Key facts

Piyush Goyal, Union Commerce and Industry Minister, spoke at Startup Mahakumbh 2025 in New Delhi, urging startups to pursue deep-tech instead of stopping at ice creams and chips.
Goyal asked whether fast delivery of ice creams and groceries qualifies as innovation, and cited China's focus on areas like AI.
Zepto CEO Aditya (Aadit) Palicha said Zepto had succeeded in creating jobs and attracting foreign direct investment.
Former Infosys CFO Mohandas Pai said Goyal should trust domestic startups and that solving startups' problems would bring success.
Murtaza Amin runs a software company in Burhanpur, Madhya Pradesh, with 100 employees and says it earns revenue of millions of dollars a year.
Amin says Burhanpur has no 24/7 power supply, that bribes are demanded for every task, and that entrepreneurs are treated like third-class citizens.
With no GST and PF offices in Burhanpur, Amin must travel 60 km to Khandwa to meet officials, which he contrasts with the Digital India claim.
Amin says he wrote last month to the PMO, some IAS officers and Piyush Goyal's office; the PMO forwarded his complaint to the Madhya Pradesh Labour Commissioner, but he received no reply.

Timeline

2016Murtaza Amin leaves a comfortable life in the United States and returns to India to be near family and create jobs.
2023 and 2024Amin's company celebrates Diwali and Holi; he later shares these photos to rebut religion-based criticism.
Last month (as stated in the source)Amin writes to the PMO, some IAS officers and Goyal's office; PMO forwards it to the MP Labour Commissioner, with no response received.
Startup Mahakumbh 2025, New DelhiGoyal makes his deep-tech versus food-delivery remarks, sparking criticism from founders and businessmen.
After the remarksAmin tweets about power cuts, bribes, official harassment and distance to GST/PF offices, and says he may shut shop and move to Dubai if targeted.

Who has a stake

Piyush Goyal / Union Ministry of Commerce and Industry — Pushing Indian startups towards deep-tech and AI for global identity; faces criticism that the state has not fixed basic enablers.
Murtaza Amin, Burhanpur startup CEO — Runs a 100-employee software firm; says he lacks power, faces bribes and officialdom, and may close the company and take a job in Dubai.
His 100 employees and their dependants — Jobs and livelihoods at risk if the company shuts; 50% of staff are women, half of them Muslim women, per Amin.
Consumer-tech startups such as Zepto — Defend their contribution to job creation and FDI against the charge that quick delivery is not innovation.
Investors and industry voices like Mohandas Pai — Want government trust in domestic startups and removal of operational hurdles.
PMO, IAS officers and the Madhya Pradesh Labour Commissioner — Grievance redressal credibility, as Amin says his letters got no response.

Why it matters

The exchange exposes a gap between India's ambition to be a global deep-tech startup hub and the everyday realities of running a company outside metro cities — unreliable electricity, absent tax and provident fund offices, and demands for bribes. Analysts quoted say India can become a global startup hub only with adequate support, infrastructure and a corruption-free environment. It also raises the risk of reverse brain drain, with a returnee founder saying he may relocate to Dubai.

UPSC angle

Prelims pointers

Startup Mahakumbh 2025 was held in New Delhi; Piyush Goyal is Union Minister for Commerce and Industry.
Goyal's remark contrasted Indian food-delivery and consumer apps with China's focus on AI and deep-tech.
Murtaza Amin's software company in Burhanpur, Madhya Pradesh, employs 100 people.
Burhanpur has no GST or PF office; the nearest is at Khandwa, 60 km away.
Aadit Palicha is CEO of Zepto; Mohandas Pai is a former CFO of Infosys.
Amin's complaint was forwarded by the PMO to the Madhya Pradesh Labour Commissioner.

Mains framing

The Goyal–Amin exchange frames a core question of India's startup policy: whether the constraint on deep-tech innovation lies in entrepreneurial ambition or in the state's delivery of basic public goods. Goyal's argument is that too much Indian capital and talent has gone into consumer-facing delivery and snack businesses rather than AI and frontier technology, limiting global identity. The counter, voiced by founders like Zepto's CEO (job creation and FDI), Mohandas Pai (trust startups, remove hurdles) and most starkly by Murtaza Amin, is that deep-tech requires reliable electricity, digital and physical proximity to regulatory offices such as GST and PF, and freedom from rent-seeking — none of which, he says, exist in a Tier-3 town like Burhanpur, where he travels 60 km to Khandwa for compliance. His account of unanswered letters to the PMO, IAS officers and the minister's office points to weak grievance redressal, while his stated intent to shut a 100-employee firm and move to Dubai signals the cost of inaction in lost jobs and talent. The way forward suggested by analysts in the source is coupling the deep-tech push with dependable infrastructure, genuine digital-first compliance and a corruption-free administrative environment, so that ambition is matched by enabling conditions beyond metro clusters.

Key terms

Startup Mahakumbh: A large startup event; its 2025 edition was held in New Delhi, where Goyal made his remarks.
Deep-tech: Startups built on advanced science and engineering such as AI, as opposed to consumer delivery apps.
GST office: Goods and Services Tax administrative office; absent in Burhanpur, forcing a 60 km trip to Khandwa.
PF office: Provident Fund office handling employee retirement contributions; also unavailable locally, per Amin.
Digital India: Government programme for digital delivery of services, which Amin questions given his need for in-person visits.
White-collar employer: Employer of salaried professional staff; Amin calls himself Burhanpur's largest such employer.

Practice questions

Is India's startup ecosystem constrained more by a lack of deep-tech ambition or by weak ease-of-doing-business fundamentals outside metro cities? Discuss with reference to recent debate.
Examine how infrastructure gaps, administrative corruption and absence of local regulatory offices in Tier-2 and Tier-3 towns affect job creation and enterprise growth.
Government grievance redressal mechanisms are only as strong as their follow-up. Critically evaluate in light of complaints forwarded between central and state authorities without response.

Grounded only in the source report — figures and dates are the source's, not inferred.

Next storyBRS MLA Vijayudu seeks restoration of Alampur lift schemes →

← All stories